Top 4 siding contractors in Sycamore, PA

"Great experience with Fahey Roofing! Thanks to the hail storm earlier this year my home was in need of a roof, gutters, and siding. We contacted numerous contractors who either didn't return our calls or never showed up for the scheduled appointment. My neighbors had used Fahey Roofing and recommended we give them a call. I'm so glad we did! Milan Mojovic came out quickly and went through everything with us. He was patient as we chose shingles for the roof and even more patient as we picked siding colors! Milan was great about getting me sample colors to look at and showing me real time jobs so I could get better idea of colors. Milan and his superintendent visited my house several times while the job was going on and when it finished up to double check everything. The end result was amazing! My house looks brand new. I recommend Fahey Roofing for anyone looking for a reliable contractor!"

"In a time that we were most stressed and vulnerable due to the April hail storms Fahey Roofing really stepped up! We had many companies banging on our door, multiple times trying to force us to use them for restoration and we really had no clue how to go about getting all the damages repaired. Josh Fahey himself made multiple visits to our home to answer any questions and made us feel ease about the processes. Once we had signed contracts with them, Damen was there to hold our hand every step of the way. If anything was less than perfect, they would make sure it was fixed to our expectations as soon as they possibly could. All of the repairs took months, but I was happy to see that once they started our project they did not rush through it and then move along to the next like I saw many other companies do. They made sure the weather was as good as it can be and then make sure to do things as I requested or would explain to me the more correct way. We had to have everything replaced roofing siding, gutters, soffit, etc. but our house looks amazing and looks brand new! More beautiful than when we first bought it! I’m so appreciative to them and they are about to start another project for me in the near future. Their pricing was great compared to many others and they did not ask to see any insurance quotes throughout the whole process!"

"I would highly recommend Fahey Roofing for your siding needs.Josh personally came out to give us our quote.Our materials took a little longer than anticipated to come in. When they did he sent his crew over right away they worked from dawn til dark very professional did an excellent job and cleaned our yard up removing all nails and construction debri.They installed new gutters also. We are very pleased with the wonderful transformation of our entire house our before and after pics below.Way to go Fahey Roofing we love our house!"

"Fahey roofing and siding are the best. I have an old house and they gave it a beautiful facelift. The process went very smooth. The employees are very hard workers. They had to fight the rain, but they still had it finished in 2 days and it looks awesome. I would highly recommend this company to anyone."

"I recently had the pleasure of working with Fahey roofing company and I couldn’t be more impressed with the entire experience. From start to finish, their professionalism, skill, and attention to detail stood out in every aspect of the project. The workmanship was truly top-notch. Every shingle was laid with precision, and the finished roof not only looks fantastic but gives me great peace of mind knowing it was done right. Their team clearly takes great pride in their craft, and it shows. Productivity was another strong point. The crew worked efficiently and stayed on schedule without sacrificing quality. I was particularly impressed with how well-coordinated the team was—every worker knew their role, and the job site operated like a well-oiled machine. Cleanup was meticulous. At the end of each day—and especially at the completion of the project—the site was left spotless. Not a nail or scrap in sight. It’s rare to see that level of care when it comes to post-project cleanup, and I truly appreciated it. The craftsmanship speaks for itself, but I also want to highlight the managerial side of things. Communication was consistent and clear throughout. The project manager was responsive, knowledgeable, and transparent with both timelines and costs. There were no surprises—just excellent service. Overall, I give Fahey roofing my highest recommendation. Their blend of skill, organization, and professionalism is rare in any industry. If you’re looking for a roofing company that delivers both quality and integrity, look no further."

"While we had fierce winds before Christmas, 2024, I was not worried about my roof. Liberty Roofing Pros replaced my roof in August, 2023. They completed the job in less than two days. Their cleanup left my yard looking as though they had never been there! The crew was courteous, efficient, fast, polite, considerate; I cannot say enough good things about Liberty Roofing Pros. I submitted an estimate request on their website one evening and Dave, the owner, called me the next morning. Travis, my representative, worked quickly and professionally with the insurance company to provide the best possible solution to my roofing troubles."

"Our experience with Liberty Roofing was exceptional. I waited a few months to post a review to be sure of the work/product quality. Both are excellent. The office staff was very friendly and worked within our budget. The roofers then followed through with a very quick installation, and they sent photos and text updates constantly. I was blown away by their service. We had a complete roof installed on our duplex, and we will be calling them again to do our porches. Much, much appreciated! Great company."

"I met up with Jim Kelly when we had wind damage in April that left a-lot of damages. The house and separate garage roof both needed replaced as well as various other smaller damages Such as the flashing on the house etc. Jim came out and checked out the damages via a drone👍🏼,so I felt confident with there recommendations Aubree also contacted my insurance company to share their findings with them in hopes of them paying for more of the damages. Which I appreciated. Then on installation day Dan and hisTeam showed up bright and early saying they would be done by 4.30PM that day! What two roofs in one day!plus replacing damaged wood that needed replaced and doing all of the other small jobs( flashing etc.). Well they finished up around 7:30 instead but they did they managed to get everything done in 1 day. Dan and his team were very friendly& respectful as was Jim. And respectful of my property especially with their clean up. The roofs look great if I can upload a picture I will do so ( before , during and after pictures)"

"Liberty roofing pros did an amazing job on my roof. We switched from a shingle roof that was 45 years old to a brand new metal roof. Liberty roof replaced rotting fascia boards and replaced bad roof panels and then expertly installed the metal roof. It looks amazing and it was nice because they are a local company and it didn’t feel like one of those big corporate companies with pushy sales and sketchy installers. Liberty roof was a hometown company for sure I would highly recommend."

"A few weeks ago Jim Kelly came out with his drone and took pictures, assured me his guys were top notch, and put us on the schedule... and then it rained and rained. It rained until yesterday. I was expecting another rain delay because it is a spring with record rain and flooding in PA where the weather report is as reliable as my ex girlfriend. So I was more than pleased when a crew showed up this morning, props to Dan the project manager, well prepared, working diligently for the next ten hours, until my roof was finished. These guys know their stuff. They worked very fast when it was appropriate and took extra time and attention where it was needed, like flashing around the chimney. Replaced wood, shingled three separate roofs on my house, full cleanup, the works, great price and photo updates on progress as it's happening. They made it look like my unique house is one they have fixed a hundred times. Can't really ask for more."

"My opinion on Ultimate Roofing, is excellent on workmanship ,and professionalism. My contacts name is Hayden and any concerns I may have had during this process of a new roof and new gutters is a over a 10 star rating. I had questions he responded in a timely fashion. Thank you Ultimate Roofing for a job really well Done! Jean McClelland"

"We had a great experience with Ultimate Roofing from start to finish. Tyler and Brian were outstanding—professional, knowledgeable, and easy to communicate with throughout the entire process. They took the time to explain everything clearly, answered all of our questions, and made sure the work was done right. The crew was efficient, respectful of our property, and the final result looks fantastic. It’s clear Tyler and Brian truly care about their work and their customers. I would highly recommend Ultimate Roofing to anyone in need of roofing services."

"We just had our entire gutter system replaced by Ultimate Roofing and I honestly couldn’t be happier with the experience!! From the very first call to the final walkthrough, this company was absolutely top notch. Their communication was incredible… every step was explained clearly, timelines were honored, and I was never left wondering what was happening next. They were also extremely transparent about pricing, options, and what work was needed and what wasn’t. That level of honesty is rare around here and in today’s world and it made the whole process stress free. On top of that, every single person we worked with was genuinely friendly, professional, and easy to talk to. It felt like working with people who truly cared about doing the job right, not just rushing through it. The new gutter system looks amazing and works perfectly. Everything was installed cleanly, efficiently, and with great attention to detail. I would absolutely recommend this company to anyone needing roofing or gutter work… they’ve easily earned my trust!!"

"We had Ultimate Roofing come out and replace our 30-year-old vinyl siding and replace several windows. They were quick with quoting, showing up at the promised time and giving us a quote right away. When it came time to do the work the crew was very professional and did high-quality work. Our 90 year old house looks like a fresh built now. All the materials installed were high quality. They were very flexible throughout the job making small adjustments as needed and requested. Cleanup was great as well. Can't even really tell they were here. In the past they'd come out to reflash our chimney with their repair department. They were the only company in the area that would take on this repair work. Everything was done at a reasonable cost."

"I will preface this review with: I am a first time homeowner. I bought my house 2 years ago, and all I will say is I hope the boy I bought my house off of took the money and paid for a rental over the next 30 years. Although I love owning my home, I have dealt with a slew of trouble with it. New septic tank, new septic lines, new leechfield, new waterlines, water well water quality needed fixed, new siding, new windows, cut over 20 trees, the list goes on. The thought of a roof terrified me to do myself, so I called ultimate. Tony (the owner) gave me my quote, and definitely helped me out in my situation. He listened to my struggles, understood the challenges I faced, and made my roof the easiest thing I have dealt with. Ultimate roofing not only went above and beyond for me, the new roof they installed looks fantastic! I no longer have to worry at night about this. There is no other brand you should even call to be honest. Ultimate is the best there is around, hands down! Thank you so much to ultimate roofing for everything they did, and making my life easier. YOU GUYS ARE THE BEST"

"We used Always Perfect for a full roof replacement. This included installing new vents, skylight, gutters, and a complete re-decking. Zach was fantastic to work with. His team was very professional and did a great job at each stage of getting our roof replaced. Zach was also very helpful and patient answering our questions. He even was able to address a few small side projects that we asked him to include in the quote which was great! Our project had a few small curveballs, but he handled them really well and we couldn’t be happier."

"We had a company completely screw up our roof (shingle over flat which is deranged behavior, bad lay job, no rake edge, poor flashing, didn’t replace damaged wood etc) and Always Perfect came through to replace our front portion (nothing on the back end could really be screwed up). I got a fair price in comparison to other well respected contractors and everything was handled professionally, honest, and with plenty of relevant communication. They took their time to do the shingles, rubber portions, and drip edge the right way. They were honest about a brick chimney that needs to be removed and made sure it was waterproofed until that could be handled. I was never hassled for money and the crew was respectful and cleaned up exceptionally well. I will absolutely use them in the future and will recommend them to others with my whole chest. Thank you, Zack!"

"The work completed was done to my high standards with careful attention to quality. The entire roof was done in one day and that includes removing the old roof, laying down OBS over existing wood, lining the box gutters and putting down the new Owens Corning shingles. The color looks great with the red brick and trim."

"Outstanding, responsive team delivered high-quality work with exceptional service! They quoted me 3 days to be finished and they got finished in one day! They even patched up the roof where we had a leak prior to us picking them. because of that and going above and beyond just giving a quote made us picked Always Perfecting Roofing. The roof turned out nice."

"Zach at Always Perfect Contracting came out to our house to assess some wind damage and replace a chimney cap that blew off our roof. He was able to build a custom cap and install it for a reasonable rate. Throughout the process he was communicative about costs and timing. It’s hard to find good contractors these days and I’m glad we found him! Looking at the new cap, I don’t think we will have any wind related issues anymore."