Metal Roofing Pros And Cons

Metal Roofing Pros and Cons

By Angelina Zhuravleva  •  April 20  •  4 min
Metal Roofing Pros and Cons

Homeowners and builders often find themselves considering various roofing materials when they are looking for the perfect option. Metal roofing is a modern option that offers durability, sustainability, and aesthetic versatility, making it an excellent choice for many. However, like any construction material, metal roofing has its own set of advantages and disadvantages. This article explores the multifaceted world of metal roofing and guides you through its pros and cons. Whether you are in the middle of a new construction project, thinking about replacing your roof, or simply curious about this roofing solution, our comprehensive guide will provide you with the knowledge you need to make an informed decision.

Pros of Metal Roofing

Metal roofing is an excellent choice for those who want to invest in their property's future. By understanding the benefits of metal roofing, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your aesthetic preferences and practical needs. Consider the following pros of metal roofing:

1. Longevity

If longevity is a priority, metal roofs fit the bill. Aluminum and steel roofs, in particular, provide decades of protection. Properly installed metal roofs can last 50+ years.

2. Cost Effective

While metal roofs have a higher upfront cost than asphalt shingles, their durability means lower long-term costs. They can also increase a home's resale value.

3. Eco-Friendly

Metal roofs are recyclable and energy efficient. Some types contain recycled materials and are eligible for tax credits.

4. Versatility

When comparing metal roofs to traditional asphalt shingles, metal roofs offer a wider range of color options. You can choose from various colors, including classic shades like black, white, and gray, as well as more vibrant red, green, or turquoise options. The type of metal used in the roof affects the available color options. Painted metals offer the most color variety, while metallic finishes showcase the natural colors of the metal. Pre-finished metals come with a baked-on enamel coating that provides good durability and a wide range of colors. Metal roofs also come in different styles and finishes, such as matte finishes for a modern look or traditional standing seam profiles for a classic appearance.

Potential Drawbacks of Metal Roofing 

Metal roofing is a popular choice due to its numerous advantages, such as durability and energy efficiency. However, before making a final roofing decision, it's important to consider the potential cons of metal roofing, as well. Although praised for its longevity and resilience, metal roofing might not be the most suitable option for every homeowner or building situation. Below, we will discuss the potential drawbacks of metal roofing.

1. Installation Challenges

Poor installation is the most common cause of problems with metal roofs. If panels aren't properly secured and sealed, leaks, denting, and noise can result. Using dissimilar metals together can lead to galvanic corrosion. Your installer should have extensive experience with metal roofing and use components compatible with your specific roofing material.

2. Maintenance is a Must

Metal roofs require regular roof inspection and maintenance, especially in areas with extreme weather. Once or twice a year, check for dents, scratches, and leaks and repair or seal them to prevent costly damage.

3. Higher Upfront Cost

While metal roofs can last 50+ years, the upfront cost is significant, from $5 to $14 per square foot installed. The investment may pay off over time, but the initial outlay can be a deterrent for many homeowners. Financing options and tax incentives can help offset some of the cost.

4. Dent and Scratch Prone

Metal roofs can easily become scratched, dented, or scuffed during installation or from fallen tree branches and other debris. This is especially true for roofs made of softer metals like aluminum and copper. Steel is more dent-resistant, but scratches or exposed metal can lead to corrosion.

5. HOA Restrictions

Some homeowners associations (HOA) have architectural guidelines restricting metal roofing due to aesthetic concerns.

6. Match Issues

If you need repairs or add-ons later, finding a perfect color match for existing metal panels can be difficult because metal roofs fade in color.

7. Rust

Metal roofs can corrode over time due to various factors. Excessive moisture from rain, snow, or humidity can cause corrosion, but this can be prevented by ensuring proper roof ventilation and sealing scratches or dents. When two different metals come in contact, an electrochemical reaction can lead to rust. This can be avoided by not mixing metal types on your roof and using non-metallic washers with metal fasteners. Additionally, airborne chemicals like salt (common in coastal areas) or industrial pollutants can speed up corrosion. Regular cleaning and maintenance can help remove these pollutants from metal roofs.

8. Oil Canning


Oil canning refers to the waviness or rippling of metal roofing panels. It does not necessarily compromise a metal roof's performance or longevity, but it can be unsightly.

9. Excessive Noise 

If not properly insulated, metal roofs can be noisier than other roofing materials during rainstorms, hail, or heavy wind. While some might find the sound of rain hitting a metal roof pleasant, it can be a disturbance for others. Adding insulation to the attic can help dampen noise from a metal roof.

Considering Metal Roofing Pros and Cons

While these metal roofing cons are important to keep in mind, many can be mitigated through proper installation techniques, quality materials, and regular maintenance. It's also worth weighing these against the long-term benefits and cost savings associated with energy efficiency, durability, and the lifespan of metal roofing when making a decision.

Directorii: The Best Metal Roof Contractors Near You

Directorii provides a comprehensive list of roofing contractors in your area who have undergone rigorous vetting. You can receive free estimates from roofing companies nearby, peruse genuine reviews, and compare prices. For every job you register on our platform, we offer a $20,000 Guarantee. Get a free quote from our contractors today.

Сontact us
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy